Brominated Vegetable Oil vs Saccharin: which is worse?

What is Brominated Vegetable Oil?

Brominated vegetable oil (BVO) is a food additive created by bonding bromine atoms to vegetable oil (typically soybean oil), creating a denser-than-water compound. When added to citrus-flavored beverages, BVO acts as an emulsifier and weighting agent, keeping citrus flavor oils evenly distributed throughout the drink rather than floating to the surface.

What is Saccharin?

Saccharin is the oldest artificial sweetener, discovered accidentally at Johns Hopkins in 1879. It is a sulfonamide compound approximately 300-400 times sweeter than sucrose with no caloric value. It has a slightly bitter metallic aftertaste at higher concentrations. Saccharin's sodium salt (sodium saccharin) is the form used in most food applications.

Documented risks

Brominated Vegetable Oil: BVO's health concerns center on bromine accumulation in body fat and tissues. Bromine is a halogen related to iodine, and it competes with iodine in the body, potentially disrupting thyroid function—a critical concern since iodine is essential for thyroid hormone synthesis. The FDA-NIH collaborative research directly triggering the 2024 ban found adverse cardiac and thyroid effects in animal studies. This FDA-NIH work, published around 2022–2023, showed effects at dose levels closer to realistic human exposure than previous studies, removing the basis for BVO's safety determination under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act's 'reasonable certainty of no harm' standard. Historical case reports of human toxicity from excessive BVO consumption document bromoderma (skin lesions), memory loss, nerve damage, tremors, and fatigue in individuals consuming large volumes of BVO-containing beverages daily. Two well-documented US cases from the 1970s and 1980s involved bromism (bromine toxicity) from chronic overconsumption. Bromine bioaccumulates in fatty tissues. Long-term sub-clinical accumulation was a concern even before the FDA ban, particularly for heavy consumers of citrus sodas. The EU, Japan, and other countries banned BVO decades ago, making the US one of the last major markets to revoke approval. The FDA issued a proposed rule in November 2023 and a final rule on July 3, 2024, effective August 2, 2024, with compliance deadline August 2, 2025, after which BVO-containing products may not be manufactured for US sale.

Saccharin: Saccharin's carcinogenicity history is one of the most tumultuous in food regulatory history. In 1977, the FDA proposed banning saccharin after studies found it caused bladder cancer in rats at very high doses. Congress passed the Saccharin Study and Labeling Act, which put a moratorium on the ban and required a cancer warning label on saccharin products ('Use of this product may be hazardous to your health. This product contains saccharin which has been determined to cause cancer in laboratory animals.'). By 2000, saccharin was removed from the US National Toxicology Program's Report on Carcinogens after subsequent research determined that the bladder cancer in male rats was caused by a rat-specific mechanism — high pH, high protein, and calcium phosphate in rat urine — that does not apply to human urine. The cancer warning label requirement was repealed. IARC also removed saccharin from its Group 2B list in 1999. However, Canada maintained its ban on food use saccharin, citing continued precautionary concern. A 2022 study in Cell found saccharin was among the artificial sweeteners most significantly altering gut microbiome composition and glucose tolerance in previously non-sweetener-using participants. Saccharin showed the largest effect on glucose tolerance among the sweeteners studied (saccharin, sucralose, aspartame, stevia). Saccharin passes through the placenta and appears in breast milk, raising questions about infant exposure that have not been fully resolved.